Palm Beach County Voted Again on Its $26 Million Convention Hotel. The Neighbors’ Lawsuit Didn’t Go Anywhere.

0
19

Photo: Farragutful, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. The proposed second hotel is unbuilt.

Palm Beach County commissioners voted 6-1 on Nov. 10 to approve the $26 million Related Ross convention hotel deal for a second time, replacing the authorization they approved in September. Two West Palm Beach neighborhood groups had sued over the first vote, asking a judge to void it. The new vote gives the county a fresh authorization, but does not, by itself, resolve the lawsuit.

The decision came after county lawyers acknowledged that legal claims had been raised about when the September agenda and supporting documents became public. The county said it was not conceding that it had broken the law, and that it stopped carrying out the deal after the claims were filed.

West Palm Now’s Nov. 11 report said the neighborhood groups’ lawyers had posted no response to the new vote on their firm’s news page as of Wednesday. The lawsuit was not reported as dismissed or decided.

A generic South Florida convention venue and plaza in daylight

Illustrative editorial photograph. This generic scene does not depict the Palm Beach County Convention Center or the proposed hotel.

Why the county held a second vote

The Oct. 14 lawsuit in Palm Beach County Circuit Court challenges the commission’s Sept. 29 approval. In the county’s Nov. 10 agenda, item 5E-1, commissioners were asked to reconsider and readopt the transaction. The agenda describes the new approval as an independent authorization that supersedes the September one.

The earlier agreements had already been signed by the mayor on Oct. 1. The county presented two new letter agreements, one for each hotel, that cancel the prior signed contracts once the replacement agreements are signed. Commissioners approved both letters 6-1, matching the vote on the transaction.

The county attorney’s office told commissioners that “legal claims were raised” concerning when the agenda and supporting papers were made public, while emphasizing that the county “is not conceding that it did anything that violated the law.” The county said it halted implementation after the claims were filed, then re-advertised the item and released the full agenda and documents on time.

The county meeting video shows the discussion and votes; the hotel item begins about two hours and 17 minutes into the recording.

Florida Politics’ Nov. 12 headline and the Palm Beach Post’s Nov. 12 coverage frame the story around parking concerns. The county’s agenda, however, makes room supply and convention-center expansion central to its case for the project.

What the deal provides

The county would buy about 1.80 acres at 940 South Rosemary Avenue from CityPlace South Tower II, a Related affiliate, for $26 million. The site is now a surface parking lot serving the existing Hilton.

A Related affiliate would finance, build and operate an 18-story, 400-room hotel. County staff described it as a full-service Curio Collection by Hilton, with about 20,800 square feet of meeting and ballroom space. The county would advance the $26 million purchase price as deposits toward construction, then take title to the completed hotel and land.

The county would lease the hotel back to the developer for an initial 33 years, with renewal options that could extend the term to 97 years. Starting annual rent would be $1,117,000, rising 3% a year. The county would also receive 6% of gross annual revenue above a $77 million threshold, which itself rises over time under the lease terms.

The hotel would join the existing Hilton in leasing 590 spaces in the convention center garage: 335 for the new hotel and 255 for the Hilton. Combined parking rent starts at $708,000 a year, with $5.1 million paid up front. The $26 million purchase funding comes from General Fund reserves.

Interior of a generic South Florida convention-center parking garage

Illustrative editorial photograph. This is not a photograph of the convention center garage or a specific hotel.

The county’s room-supply argument

County staff said the new hotel would bring the number of rooms next to the convention center to 800, with 640 held for convention bookings. The agenda says the expanded convention center would need about 600 more nearby rooms.

The county also presented 97-year projections: a hotel and land value of $349 million; $1.1 billion in base and parking rent; as much as $7 billion in revenue-share rent if hotel revenue grows 5% annually; and 320 ongoing jobs, including 255 at the hotel.

Those are the county’s own long-range estimates in future dollars. They are not adjusted for inflation or converted to present value, and the revenue-share figure depends on the stated growth assumption. County Administrator Joseph Abruzzo said he and his chief deputy negotiated with Related Ross for six to eight weeks “to get the billion dollar guarantee.” That characterization should be read alongside the agenda’s projections and contract terms: the projected totals are not present-value figures, and the potential revenue share is contingent on hotel performance.

Weiss opposed the deal, but not a second hotel

Commissioner Gregg Weiss, whose District 2 includes the site, voted no on every motion. The purchase required at least five votes from the seven-member commission.

Weiss said he supported adding a second hotel: “I think we need this hotel.” He also called the deal better than the arrangement for the existing hotel. His objections were to its details.

He said 590 garage spaces were “absolutely not enough” for two hotels. He also argued that county ownership would take the property off the tax rolls, affecting other taxing bodies, including the city, the Health Care District and the Children’s Services Council. He said the county could have done more to protect neighbors beside the site. No public figure quantifying the tax-roll impact was identified in the Nov. 10 agenda or the cited reporting.

About 15 people asked to speak at the meeting, each receiving three minutes. Some opposed the deal; one speaker said the new vote was intended to make the lawsuit “go away.”

Generic convention-center ballroom set for an event

Illustrative editorial photograph. This does not depict the Palm Beach County Convention Center or a specific event.

What happens next

The county can now sign the replacement agreements and proceed with the purchase. The Nov. 10 agenda does not set a construction date.

West Palm Beach approved the hotel’s design on Aug. 31. The neighborhood groups have a separate lawsuit pending over that approval, in addition to the suit asking a judge to void the September county vote. The revote replaces the earlier county authorization, but the public record cited here does not establish that either lawsuit has ended.

The next steps remain open: when construction might begin, what becomes of the two live suits, and how much the county-ownership structure could mean for the tax rolls. An exposure that has not been publicly quantified.