Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier says his office will no longer defend convictions under the state’s bump stock ban on appeal. But his declaration that the law is “dead” is a characterization, not a court ruling or repeal.
The distinction matters: Florida’s 2018 bump stock ban remains on the books. The Legislature has not repealed it, and no court has struck it down in the reporting on this announcement. What has changed is the position of the state’s top lawyer: Attorney General James Uthmeier says his office will no longer defend convictions under the law on appeal, asserting that the statute is unconstitutional.
Uthmeier announced the change Friday, Nov. 13, and highlighted a formal legal opinion from his office. The opinion is not a judicial decision and does not bind courts. It sets out the attorney general’s view of the law; it does not, by itself, erase the statute or settle how courts will handle cases.
The announcement puts a new question in front of Florida’s courts and prosecutors, and a particularly immediate one in Broward County, where the law’s origins are inseparable from the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland.
What Uthmeier said, and what changed
In a post on X, Uthmeier said the law, “As currently written, the overly broad law appears to restrict the use of trigger enhancements used by firearms owners for lawful purposes, subjecting them to five years in prison.”
The opinion cited in the post argues that the state has prohibited an entire class of firearm components that can increase the rate of fire of a semiautomatic weapon. It says those firearms, with such modifications, are “bearable arms covered by the Second Amendment’s plain text.”
That is the attorney general’s legal position. The immediate practical change is narrower: his office will no longer defend convictions under the ban on appeal. The reporting does not establish how many people are imprisoned or charged under the statute, whether a particular pending appeal prompted the move, or what will happen in any individual case.

File photo from Oct. 4, 2017, of a bump stock attached to a semiautomatic rifle at a Utah gun store and shooting range, via AP and WLRN. This image depicts the device, not the Florida statute.
It is also not established whether any prosecutor will stop bringing charges under the law. Uthmeier’s position concerns his office’s defense of convictions on appeal; it should not be described as a statewide court order or as proof that enforcement has ended.
The federal ban was overturned. Florida’s remained.
Bump stocks are devices that increase the rate of fire of a semiautomatic weapon. They became a focus of gun-control efforts after the Oct. 1, 2017, mass shooting in Las Vegas. A gunman fired more than 1,000 rounds from his 32nd-floor hotel balcony onto an outdoor concert, killing 58 people and wounding more than 400.
In 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the federal bump stock ban in a 6-3 decision. The ruling said the device still requires the trigger to be “released and reengaged to fire each additional shot,” and therefore does not convert a semiautomatic weapon into an automatic firearm. Automatic weapons are banned under federal law.
That federal decision did not remove Florida’s state-level ban. The state law remained in place after the Supreme Court ruling, and it is that statute Uthmeier now says his office will not defend on appeal.
The legal questions are distinct: the Supreme Court addressed the federal ban, while Uthmeier’s opinion addresses Florida’s law. His opinion does not substitute for a court ruling on the state statute.
A law written after Parkland
Florida lawmakers included the bump stock ban in a major school-safety and gun legislation package in 2018, following the Feb. 14 mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. Seventeen people were killed, including 14 children.
The families and the school shooting are the reason the statute was written. The measure also funded school-safety efforts, created a “guardian” program to train armed school personnel, raised the rifle purchase age from 18 to 21 and enacted “red flag” laws allowing police to seize weapons from people deemed a threat to themselves or others.
The package passed with bipartisan support, but it divided members of both parties. Then-Gov. Rick Scott signed it and has defended it as a necessary tool. Some Republicans opposed its gun-control provisions; some Democrats, including Black lawmakers, objected to the prospect of arming school personnel.

The policy now faces a different kind of uncertainty. Uthmeier has announced how his office will handle appeals, but the reporting does not establish whether lawmakers intend to revisit the statute or whether prosecutors elsewhere will change their approach. For Broward County, where Parkland’s families and community have a direct connection to the law’s passage, how the change affects enforcement is a live question.
The timing, and the limits of what it tells us
The announcement comes three weeks after an election and days after Byron Donalds won the governorship. Donalds, then a member of the Florida House, voted against the 2018 bill and has spoken out against its gun-control measures on the campaign trail.
Those events overlap in time. The available reporting does not establish that Donalds’ election caused Uthmeier’s decision, and it would be premature to draw that conclusion.
For now, the known change is the attorney general’s position on appeals. The statute remains in Florida law. The opinion is not a ruling, and it does not answer what courts will decide in future cases or whether prosecutors will continue bringing charges.

The attorney general’s opinion does not replace a court decision. Illustrative photo.
What to watch next
The next developments to follow are whether courts consider Uthmeier’s constitutional argument, whether the Legislature takes up the statute and whether prosecutors make public decisions about charging. None of those outcomes is established in the current reporting.
For South Florida readers, the immediate takeaway is straightforward: the state’s attorney general says his office will stop defending bump stock convictions on appeal, but the law has not been repealed or struck down. The gap between that announcement and any change in how the statute is applied will be important to watch, especially in Broward County, where the law began as part of the response to Parkland.
Sources: WLRN / News Service of Florida report by Gray Rohrer · Florida Attorney General’s formal opinion
Follow South Florida Digest for continuing coverage of the issues shaping South Florida.

