A Judge Struck Down Florida’s Net-Worth Disclosure Law. More Than 100 Officials Already Quit Over It.

0
18

Illustrative image.

Nov. 19, 2026

A federal judge has ruled that parts of Florida’s expanded financial-disclosure requirements for local officials violate the First Amendment. The decision is a legal victory for municipal officers who challenged the law, and a reminder of the policy dispute behind the case: how much financial detail should the public be able to demand from people serving in local government?

The consequences have already reached beyond the courtroom. More than 100 elected officials statewide reportedly stepped down after the law passed, citing its expanded disclosure requirements, according to reporting by WLRN.

The ruling does not repeal the law. It addresses the compelled disclosures challenged in court, and the judge plans to issue a permanent injunction that would make those requirements unenforceable. The parties still have to work out the injunction’s terms.

A close view of a generic financial disclosure form with blank lines and boxes, with no readable personal information

Illustrative image.

What the law required

The case concerns Florida’s 2023 “Ethics Requirements for Public Officials” bill, SB 774. The measure required local government officers and candidates to disclose their precise net worth and any source of income greater than $1,000.

The Florida Commission on Ethics pushed the measure as a way to increase transparency in local government finances and bring municipal disclosure rules into line with those for state constitutional officers. The Commission declined WLRN’s request for comment, citing ongoing litigation.

For local candidates and officials, the change meant a substantially more detailed public accounting of personal finances. The requirement prompted objections from municipal leaders who said public service should not mean making a detailed inventory of private assets available to everyone.

The challenge was brought in 2024 by 175 municipal officers. They argued that the state could not compel them to publish financial information they otherwise would not have disclosed.

The First Amendment issue

U.S. District Judge Melissa Damian ruled earlier this month that parts of SB 774 are unconstitutional. In her Nov. 9 order, Damian agreed that the mandatory disclosures at issue implicated the First Amendment because they compelled officials to provide detailed personal financial information that would be publicly available.

“The mandated disclosures at issue involve detailed personal financial information of public, elected officials, and it is undisputed that the information will be publicly available,” Damian wrote. “Laws that require disclosure of information, including both government reporting requirements and direct disclosure requirements, are subject to First Amendment scrutiny.”

That is the core of the ruling: compelled disclosure is subject to First Amendment scrutiny. The decision is not a finding that financial transparency is inherently undesirable, or that the state has no interest in public accountability. It addresses the constitutional limits on requiring people to make particular information public.

That distinction matters in a debate where both concerns are real. Residents have a legitimate interest in understanding whether public officials’ financial ties could affect decisions made in office. Officials, in turn, argued that the law required an unusually detailed public accounting of personal finances.

Fortuna Smukler, a North Miami Beach commissioner, told WLRN: “I don't necessarily agree that everybody in the world should know our private business. It's enough that our life is a public record. Now we have to tell them how much money we have in the bank, how many diamonds we have in the house, how much artwork.”

Smukler also argued that making information about household assets public could expose officials to burglary. That concern was part of the objections raised by local leaders; the court’s ruling, however, centers on compelled disclosure and First Amendment scrutiny.

A modest South Florida city hall exterior with tropical landscaping and a sign for the commission chamber

Illustrative image.

Why the local-office impact matters

This is a story about municipal government: the commissioners, council members and candidates whose work touches day-to-day decisions in cities and towns. The state-level disclosure rules were the model for the expanded local requirements, but the lawsuit was brought by municipal officers challenging what they would be required to disclose.

That local focus makes the case consequential for South Florida communities, where decisions made by city commissions and village councils shape services, development and neighborhood priorities. Financial disclosure can help residents assess potential conflicts of interest. The question raised in court was whether the state could compel this level of personal disclosure from local officials and candidates.

Joshua Simmons, a former Coral Springs commissioner who signed onto the lawsuit, told WLRN that he believed SB 774 would discourage people from running for office, even though he agreed that government transparency is important.

That concern is borne out in the resignations reported after the bill passed. More than 100 elected officials statewide reportedly left office specifically citing the expanded disclosure requirements. The available reporting does not identify those officials by name in the WLRN account, and it does not provide a county-by-county breakdown.

The figure is the most tangible measure of the law’s impact so far. A permanent injunction may make the challenged disclosure requirements unenforceable, but it will not bring back people who have already left office. Nor does the court ruling, by itself, resolve the broader policy argument about how to balance scrutiny of public officials with their privacy.

What happens next

The court had already paused SB 774 when the lawsuit began. Damian now plans to issue a permanent injunction, and the parties must meet with her before the end of November to work out its terms.

Until those terms are set, it is important to be precise about what has happened: the judge ruled that parts of the law are unconstitutional, and an injunction is planned to make the challenged requirements unenforceable. The law has not been repealed.

WLRN has not reported whether the state will appeal or whether attorney’s fees will be sought or awarded. Those questions remain unreported.

For residents following Florida politics, the immediate takeaway is both legal and practical. The ruling says that mandatory disclosures of detailed personal financial information are subject to First Amendment scrutiny. The resignations show how the requirements affected local public service before the court reached its decision.

Transparency and compelled speech are not interchangeable questions. Florida’s courts have now ruled on the constitutional issue in this case. The policy debate, and the local-government vacancies left in the law’s wake, remain part of the story.