Florida Is Paying Homeowners to Install a Septic System Nobody Has Finished Testing

0
27

Illustrative image.

Florida is offering more than $10 million in grants to help homeowners upgrade septic systems and reduce pollution reaching rivers, springs and groundwater. But some of that money could pay for a technology that experts say has not been tested enough to show how well it performs over time.

In a Nov. 12 report by WLRN and WUFT News, reporter Rose Schnabel found that Florida has allowed contractors to install more than 5,500 so-called biofilters despite limited data on their performance and no established lifespan. The systems do not require routine inspections or continuous monitoring.

The state’s incentive is clear: reduce nitrogen pollution that can harm waterways. The unresolved question is whether the systems installed in homeowners’ yards are reliably delivering the reductions expected of them.

A water-quality problem with a statewide reach

Biofilters use layers of sand and wood chips containing microbes to convert forms of nitrogen in wastewater into nitrogen gas. According to WLRN and WUFT, the systems were among three advanced septic options the state will require on tens of thousands of properties by 2030, with more requirements to follow. Local rules and deadlines vary.

The concern extends beyond the counties receiving the latest grants. The reporting’s examples and the new funding counties are all in North Florida, but the state rules apply across Florida. Nitrogen pollution is also part of the broader water-quality challenge facing the Everglades and South Florida’s waterways. The reporting does not provide South Florida installation or grant figures.

Florida has about 2.6 million septic systems, more than any other state, according to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, as cited by WLRN and WUFT. Conventional systems were designed to remove pathogens and protect public health, not to capture nutrients, said Mary Lusk, a University of Florida professor in soil, water and ecosystem sciences. The reporting notes that state research found septic systems could release nutrients into groundwater even when operating properly.

A concrete septic access lid in grass with a Florida home in the background

Illustrative image.

The design target is not proof of field performance

The biofilter concept emerged from research commissioned by the state. In 2009, consultant Damann Anderson led a team working on affordable nitrogen-reducing septic options. His firm, Hazen & Sawyer, spent $4.7 million and six years researching and refining possible systems, according to WLRN and WUFT.

The biofilter prototypes were relatively inexpensive and easy to install. The report’s testing indicated they could meet the state’s 65% nitrogen-reduction requirement, about three times the roughly 30% efficacy of conventional systems. But that figure came from prototypes and early testing, not a demonstrated result for every biofilter later installed in the field.

Anderson said the early results were preliminary and called for more testing. “We had only looked at a couple of them,” he told WLRN and WUFT. “And it's like, ‘Okay, you guys, that's going great, but you need to put 10 or 20 more in and monitor them.’”

The Florida Department of Health’s final report to the Legislature cautioned that more steps were needed before implementation, including residential testing to establish how long wood chips last and what monitoring and maintenance systems would be required. WLRN and WUFT report that installation codes were created before pilot sites, and contractors had installed biofilters for three years before state agencies began their own testing.

The code also does not require several components in the research report’s design, including a liner, a specified wood-chip and sand blend, and pipes designed to distribute water evenly. Greg Mayfield, president of the Florida Onsite Wastewater Association, questioned whether field installations are achieving the results shown in the research. Anthony Gaudio, a retired septic installer, said missing components could leave parts of a system removing nitrogen effectively while other sections allow pollutants through, according to the reporting.

Low oversight is part of the appeal

Biofilters do not require monitoring equipment or routine inspections, according to WLRN and WUFT. Independent contractors inspect them twice during installation, after which the systems can operate without ongoing checks.

That contrasts with aerobic treatment units, another advanced option that the reporting says is rigorously tested and third-party certified. Those units require permits, maintenance agreements and inspections, and can add about $20 a month to electricity bills. The additional oversight and cost can make biofilters more attractive to homeowners.

But without regular monitoring, a system may release nutrients without an obvious warning to the homeowner. Toilets can continue to work while pollution goes undetected, the experts told WLRN and WUFT.

Tallahassee contractor Brian Miller said he has installed about 1,000 biofilters in North Florida. He told the news organizations that about 100 systems he installed have had the ground sink and settle as wood chips rot, disrupting water flow and causing toilets to stop working. That is one contractor’s experience, not a statewide failure rate. Miller said all of those systems had passed inspection and that no study has definitively determined how long biofilters last.

A canal or spring run with dark water and vegetation beside a suburban lot

Illustrative image.

Grants are moving ahead while key questions remain

Alachua County has received state grants to offer rebates of $10,000 for biofilters and $16,000 for aerobic systems in two river basins, according to WLRN and WUFT. County water resources program manager Stacie Greco said about 200 people had expressed interest a month after the program was announced.

On Oct. 28, Gov. Ron DeSantis announced more than $10 million in additional septic-upgrade grant funding for Alachua, Citrus, Leon, Marion and Volusia counties. WLRN and WUFT report that if past installation trends continue, a significant portion could go toward biofilters.

The Florida Department of Environmental Protection’s onsite sewage research page describes a performance-evaluation project for biofilters that includes residential sampling and inspection. Its published materials, as reported by WLRN and WUFT, list five test sites with average nitrogen reductions ranging from 42% to 83% and say more data is needed for a robust evaluation.

Anderson told WLRN and WUFT, “I just don't want to see all this money spent and then we don't gain what we think we're gaining for water quality.”

The accountability gap remains: no agency has said how many biofilters it has monitored, and no study has established how long they last.