Miami-Dade Approved a Megayacht Marina Before Anyone Answered the Manatee Questions

0
26

Miami-Dade County’s planning board has advanced a proposal for a new entertainment district at the Miami Seaquarium site, but the key issue is what came first. On Monday, Nov. 16, the board unanimously recommended the land-use application to county commissioners while environmental questions about the marina remained under review.

That distinction matters. The recommendation is not final approval of the redevelopment, its 99-year lease or the marina permits. Yet the application would make room for a marina whose effects on manatees and Biscayne Bay regulators say have not been fully assessed.

In a report posted Friday, the county’s Department of Environmental Resources Management (DERM) said two earlier environmental studies submitted by developer David Martin’s Resilient Aquarium team did not account for the full project. The report described nearly 300 wet boat slips and another 552 boats in dry-stack storage. It also said the studies relied on data that show a snapshot of manatee behavior, rather than how the animals move through the bay.

As planning chief Garrett Rowe explained at the hearing, environmental concerns would be addressed later as the project is designed. That sequencing, not a final go-ahead for construction, is the central tension in this latest step.

What the board recommended, and what it did not

The board’s vote concerned a land-use application to establish a new entertainment district. Under that application, the district would set a limit of 295 wet slips.

That number needs to be kept separate from the project’s broader marina description. DERM’s report refers to nearly 300 wet slips plus 552 dry-stack spaces. The district’s 295-slip figure is a cap on wet slips; it does not, by itself, answer the concerns raised about the marina’s overall scope or environmental effects.

Rowe told board members that several processes are moving forward at once. Those include the land-use application, a new 99-year lease, a zoning application and regulatory permits to build in the Biscayne Bay Aquatic Preserve. The lease, zoning application and marina permits are still pending.

“There are several things occurring at the same time,” Rowe said, explaining that the other processes are being handled separately. “But the primary subject of this hearing is the [land use] application.”

Some board members said they had not previously seen an application divided into pieces this way. Michael Montiel, whose district includes Virginia Key, said he understood that environmental matters would be addressed during permitting but wanted the concerns entered into the record.

“I believe strongly that this has not been fully vetted on the environmental side,” Montiel said.

Illustrative photograph of a manatee swimming above a seagrass bed

Illustrative image: Manatees use seagrass habitats in Biscayne Bay; this is not a photograph of the project site.

Why regulators are asking for more

DERM’s concern is not limited to what happens at the docks. The department warned that marina traffic could shift toward nearby seagrass flats where manatees graze.

“Placement of a marina expansion in an area that is utilized by manatees as well as vessels for travel may cause negative impacts,” the report said.

The department also criticized the boating data used in Martin’s analysis. The study relied on 2009 figures, when about 58,000 boats were registered in Miami-Dade County. By 2024, that number had risen to nearly 74,000, according to the report.

Two other reports, one from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and one from Save the Manatee Club, found that manatees frequent the area. Both recommended limiting the total number of slips to 250. The recommended 250 is below the district’s 295-wet-slip cap.

The difference does not settle the dispute over how many boats the site can accommodate safely. Nor does a cap on wet slips establish what the eventual permits will allow. Those questions remain for the processes still underway.

Plan image showing the proposed marina at the Seaquarium site

The land-use application caps wet slips at 295. The broader marina plan described by DERM also includes dry-stack storage.

The acreage dispute

The way the project is being measured has become another point of contention. The existing Seaquarium site covers about 35 acres. The marina would add nearly 60 acres, much of it in the bay.

Environmental groups allege the county is keeping the land-use application below the 50-acre threshold so it can proceed as a “small-scale” amendment, rather than face more detailed state review. Their criticism is that the marina acreage is not included in the land-use application’s project area, even though the marina is tied to the redevelopment.

That is the groups’ characterization of the review structure; it is not a finding by the planning board. Still, the acreage figures help explain why the sequence and scope of the applications drew scrutiny at the hearing.

Aaron Stauber, a plaintiff in a lawsuit seeking a voter referendum on the project, challenged the focus on the original site acreage. “Now is exactly when your responsibility matters,” he told board members. “Only 35 acres? C’mon, we know that’s not the whole project.”

The referendum lawsuit remains unresolved.

Aerial view of the Virginia Key shoreline and the Seaquarium grounds, with the Buckminster Fuller dome visible

Aerial view of the Seaquarium site and adjacent shoreline on Virginia Key. The proposal includes a marina as part of a wider redevelopment.

A broader redevelopment, with major steps still ahead

The plan has elements board members praised: restoration of the Buckminster Fuller gold dome and the Flipper house, a public bayfront walkway and a new aquarium. The University of Miami is leasing property at the site for a science center.

Martin has said a team from UM’s Rosenstiel School is serving as science advisers. One member said only two meetings had taken place so far, and the university did not respond to multiple requests for details about the plan.

Those proposed amenities help explain the appeal of a major Seaquarium makeover. They do not resolve the environmental questions surrounding the marina. The board’s recommendation moves the land-use application forward, but other decisions remain: the 99-year lease, zoning application and regulatory permits for construction in the Aquatic Preserve are still pending. The referendum lawsuit is also unresolved.

For residents following the Virginia Key project, the next milestones will show whether the remaining reviews address the issues DERM raised: the full marina scope, how manatees move through Biscayne Bay, and the potential for new boat traffic near seagrass habitat.

Read WLRN Public Media’s full report by Jenny Staletovich, along with its coverage of the FWC and Save the Manatee Club recommendations. Follow South Florida Digest for updates on the decisions still ahead.