Miami Votes Next Week on Dismantling Its Own Anti-Discrimination Office. One Commissioner Calls It a Brand Problem.

0
29

Photo: David Villano for the Spotlight, via WLRN.

Miami’s City Commission is slated to vote next week on an ordinance that would reshape how the city handles discrimination complaints and remove most of the authority of its LGBTQ Advisory Board.

The proposal, reported by Tess Riski of The Florida Trib and republished by WLRN, is framed as a response to Florida Senate Bill 1134, which is set to take effect Jan. 1. The law bars local governments from funding, promoting or taking official action on diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives, according to the reporting and the state’s bill record.

The Miami measure would eliminate the Equal Opportunity Advisory Board and the Equal Opportunity Diversity Programs, which fields internal employment discrimination complaints. It would also repeal the city’s affirmative action policy and strip the LGBTQ Advisory Board of its powers and duties.

The ordinance would require another vote before it could be finalized. If commissioners give it a green light next week, it must return for a second and final vote.

The board would remain, but lose its role

The proposal’s most specific change is also its most unusual: Miami’s LGBTQ Advisory Board would technically continue to exist, but lose the city attorney assigned to it and have its powers and duties removed from city code.

Those powers include making recommendations to the City Commission, promoting positive images of the LGBTQ community, encouraging and attracting LGBTQ businesses, conducting fact-finding about issues affecting the community and serving as a forum for concerns related to homophobia and transphobia.

The city’s current description of the board says it advises the commission on improving quality of life for LGBTQ residents and visitors, and provides a platform for underrepresented individuals and communities. Under the proposed ordinance, that advisory function would be substantially curtailed.

The legislation includes a provision that would restore the board’s powers if SB 1134 is repealed or deemed unconstitutional.

Miami Pride flag displayed on the city’s LGBTQ+ Advisory Board page

The City of Miami’s LGBTQ+ Advisory Board page displays the city’s Pride flag.

The proposal also would repeal a city affirmative action policy stating that Miami has “an ethical and moral responsibility to provide fair and equitable consideration of applicants and employees, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, age, national origin, place of birth, marital status or physical or mental handicap.”

The ordinance cites the new state law but does not name a sponsor. The Florida Trib reported that it is unclear who filed it.

What happens to discrimination complaints?

The Equal Opportunity Diversity Programs currently fields internal employment discrimination complaints. Under the proposal, that program and the Equal Opportunity Advisory Board would be eliminated. In their place, the city would “establish a reporting and investigatory protocol and procedure” for discrimination and retaliation claims within the human resources department, “as permitted” under the state law.

The proposal describes a new protocol, but the reporting does not identify how that process would work in practice, who would administer it or what procedural steps a city employee could expect. That leaves an important operational question: if the existing program is deleted, how will Miami receive, investigate and resolve discrimination complaints through the replacement HR process?

An unmarked form and document tray on a public-service office desk

Illustrative image.

The legislation proposes moving the reporting and investigation protocol into Human Resources. The terms and operation of that protocol are not detailed in the reporting.

The question is about the mechanics of the proposal, not a prediction about how any future system would perform. The text described in the report would transfer the function into HR while eliminating the existing program. The details of the replacement procedure will matter to employees seeking to make complaints.

Pardo says he will vote no

Commissioner Damian Pardo, Miami’s first openly gay commissioner and founder of LGBTQ advocacy organization SAVE, told The Florida Trib he will vote against the ordinance. Pardo previously served on the city’s LGBTQ Advisory Board.

“All of this hurts us. It hurts our economy. It hurts our brand throughout the world. This is something that affects real lives and real people. It has consequences,” Pardo told the publication.

He also called SB 1134 “a travesty when it passed, one more example of state overreach on a local matter, clearly targeting LGBTQ residents and other groups,” and said the law “should be repealed immediately.”

Pardo pointed to the recent midterm results, saying that if they are “any indication, voters are tired of culture wars and want us to get down to the business of serving their needs.”

Miami-Dade County had 61 percent voter turnout, according to the reporting. Voters chose Democrat Angie Nixon over incumbent U.S. Sen. Ashley Moody, David Jolly over Republican Byron Donalds for governor, and Democrat Jose Javier Rodriguez over incumbent Attorney General James Uthmeier. Miami elected Eileen Higgins mayor last year, making her the city’s first Democratic mayor in decades.

The upcoming commission vote places that political backdrop alongside a concrete local proposal to comply with the state law before its January effective date. The mayor does not vote on the City Commission but has veto power. Higgins did not respond to The Florida Trib’s request for comment on whether she would consider a veto if the legislation passed.

For now, the commission’s next step is a scheduled vote. The result is not yet known, and any initial approval would still require a second and final vote.