Seven Everglades Projects Are Done and the Benefits Are Showing. The Scientists Just Asked a Harder Question.

0
27

Illustrative image.

Seven Everglades restoration projects or major components are complete. Some ecological benefits are visible, and construction is moving faster than it has in years. But the scientists reviewing the work say South Florida still lacks a consistent way to determine which projects are producing which results, and the effort faces a major unresolved test: meeting the water-quality standard required before the Everglades Agricultural Area Reservoir can operate at full capacity.

That is the central tension in the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine’s 2026 biennial review, published in October. As Inside Climate News’ Amy Green reported Nov. 11, the review describes a nearly 26-year, multibillion-dollar restoration effort that has shifted from planning toward operations. It also presses agencies to define what success means and show, with stronger evidence, whether the Everglades is getting there.

The National Academies, a private nonprofit, has issued biennial reviews of the restoration's progress since 2004 under a congressional mandate.

More projects are moving from construction to operation

The National Academies said the pace of restoration increased substantially over the 2024–2026 review period, supported by record funding and better collaboration between federal and state agencies. The report points to increased priority for major work, including the EAA Reservoir south of Lake Okeechobee.

Seven Everglades restoration projects are complete, according to the review. Among the completed work are reservoirs east and west of Lake Okeechobee designed to help manage harmful lake discharges associated with algae blooms. Those blooms have sickened residents and killed marine life. The Everglades watershed also supplies drinking water to millions of people.

The EAA Reservoir remains under construction and is scheduled for completion in 2029. The National Academies review identifies it as a major priority in the restoration program. Its eventual operation, however, depends on meeting a separate water-quality requirement.

South Florida water-control gate beside a wetland

Illustrative image.

The report describes several signs of change on the ground. In Everglades National Park, dry-season flows east of Taylor Slough have improved, although effects on salinity in Florida Bay remain difficult to discern. Flows in Shark River Slough have increased, particularly during the dry season. In Picayune Strand, vegetation is transitioning from upland to wetland.

Those are encouraging observations, but the report warns that analysis of the benefits “has not been consistent.” In plain terms, projects are being built and operated faster than monitoring and analysis can keep pace. Without consistent, quantitative follow-up, it is difficult to separate the effects of a particular project from rainfall, other water-management decisions or changes elsewhere in the system.

That gap limits what scientists and the public can conclude from the early results. The National Academies says uneven analysis weakens understanding of restoration progress and reduces opportunities to learn from completed projects.

Water quality is the condition the reservoir cannot bypass

The National Academies identifies water quality as a binding constraint on the EAA Reservoir’s full operation. A new standard, the Water Quality-Based Effluent Limitation, or WQBEL, took effect this year. It measures nutrient pollution associated with fertilizer use on sugar farms south of Lake Okeechobee.

Before the reservoir can operate at full capacity, the standard must be met for at least five years. According to the report, it had not been met through water year 2025. Water years run from May 1 through April 30.

The scientists warn that if existing strategies do not bring the water into compliance, “aggressive and possibly contentious new actions” will likely be needed. They raised similar concerns in their 2022 and 2024 reviews.

Steve Davis, chief science officer at the Everglades Foundation, told Inside Climate News that the two most feasible options are further reducing pollution from sugar farms or expanding the engineered stormwater treatment areas that filter nutrients from water. Davis said both approaches would be costly and politically difficult.

“We have to hit the water quality mark. There is no compromise on that,” Davis said.

The issue is not simply whether the reservoir is built. The water entering the system has to meet the applicable standard, and the five-year requirement has to be fulfilled before the reservoir can operate at full capacity.

Wildlife protections expose difficult trade-offs

The report also raises concerns about the loss of federal staff responsible for Endangered Species Act protections. One example is the Cape Sable seaside sparrow, an endangered bird in the Everglades.

During nesting season, some water-control structures are closed to protect the sparrow. Those closures can restrict water flow and contribute to flooding of tree islands, which are important to the Miccosukee Tribe as well as plant and animal life. Sea level rise has made the competing water-management pressures worse, the report says.

The trade-off is direct: water managers must protect the bird’s nesting habitat while also managing water levels and flows that affect other parts of the Everglades. The report’s concern about federal staffing is that these decisions, reviews and project analyses require people as well as funding.

“It takes not only funding, but it takes staff to analyze these project reports,” said Casey Darling Kniffin, policy director at Friends of the Everglades, as quoted by Inside Climate News.

Water sampling equipment beside Everglades marsh

Illustrative image.

What counts as success in a changing Everglades?

The National Academies says the definition of restoration success will need to evolve as scientists learn more about sea level rise, invasive species and other changing conditions. Even when the plan is complete, the Everglades will remain a highly managed system, the report says, pressed by urban development, water supply, flood control and legal requirements, as well as climate change, peat loss, legacy nutrients and invasive species.

That does not mean the goal should be lowered without evidence. Kniffin cautioned against redefining success simply to claim a victory for the plan.

“We have to be careful about changing the goal post just to claim victory on the plan without seeing the ecological benefits,” she said.

The National Academies’ larger point is that agencies need clearer measures of desired outcomes and stronger ways to track whether projects deliver them. A completed structure is a construction milestone. A change in water flow is an observation. Showing how those changes affect the wider ecosystem, and whether they meet agreed restoration goals, requires sustained monitoring and analysis.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers said it is working with state, tribal and institutional partners to review the report. The South Florida Water Management District said it was focused at the moment on a recent rain event that caused flooding in coastal areas of central and southeast Florida.

The political transition is brief but relevant to the effort’s continuity: Gov. Ron DeSantis’ second term ends in January, and Republican Byron Donalds was elected to succeed him. Donalds has vowed to make the Everglades a priority.

Separately from the National Academies review, the proposed Southland Water Resource Project, a limestone mine on 8,632 acres next to the EAA Reservoir, faces a Dec. 1 deadline to answer the water district’s questions. South Florida Digest has reported on the proposal.

The five-year WQBEL clock has not started. The reservoir remains scheduled for completion in 2029 on paper. And the report says nobody has yet defined success well enough to know whether it arrives.